Good VS Evil (Logos)
People are not simple good or evil, everyone is a combination
of both. The podcast shows that Fritz Haber was a combination of light and
dark. He was a German scientist who came up with a way to increase the
production of food by producing more nitrogen. He saved billions of people because
as the number of humans increased in the world people began to outnumber food
resources. He took a nitrogen out of the air and was able to produce food with
it. This was a great accomplishment and Haber was celebrated for the lives he
saved and that people were not starving. When World War I broke out Haber
volunteers himself to help Germany in the war. He uses the nitrogen he used to
feed the population to make another chemical called Ammonium. He used the
chemical against people in the war. People were in trenches and he used the
Ammonium to gas all of those people and kill them. It was almost cheating
because prior to this it wasn’t the way war was supposed to be done. Germany
lost the war and then Hitler took over. Fritz Haber was part Jew so he was not
allowed to be on the German Scientist Staff. He was very angered about this
because he took a lot of pride in his country. He roamed around awhile homeless
then he dies. One of the strangest parts about this is that during World War I
his staff created a chlorine gas that he knew about. When the Nazis took over
they removed the warning smell from the chemical and they use it as the choking
gas that killed the Jews in the concentration camp. This is terrible because he
played a major role in killing people who were just like him some who might
have even been family. The guy did an amazing thing by finding a way to feed
billions of people with nitrogen but the same nitrogen he uses to do that is what
is used to kill people in war and in the Holocaust. People are much too complex
to simply label them or their actions good or evil.
In The Flawed Concept of Good VS Evil Imgur says that “Evil
is innate natural in all humans”. I agree with this quote because just as evil
is natural so is good. Imgur later says
that evil is always their but it can be controlled. If humans were naturally
just good or bad we wouldn’t have to learn how to behave properly or learn the
difference between right or wrong because it would already be built into us,
but we do have to learn because we aren’t born able to differentiate between
the two. Some people are better at controlling the evil within them and those
are the people who are considered good in our society. The ones who have more
trouble controlling themselves are deemed bad and often find their way to
institutions such as prison.
Ethos: I agree with you. People can be a combination of both good and evil. Like in the podcast, Fritz Habber was both evil and good. He was good when he discovered that nitrogen could help plants grow more, and he discovered how nitrogen could be brought down to the dirt. The evil in him was during World War I, he discovered nitrogen could be created to make bombs and he made chloride to gas his enemies and kill humans, Zyklon A during World War I and Zyklon B, during World War II. In "The Flawed Concept of Good vs. Evil" he says "...evil is not something that can ever be conquered or defeated evil is natural, and good is born in us. I believe everyone has a little bit of good and evil in them.
ReplyDelete