The reading required plenty of abstract thinking to
understand. The basis of the reading was how bewilderment can be poetic or
politics. He tells us the importance of bewilderment but also of logic. He
recites many poems and shows how bewilderment is a part of each poem. I like
poetry like this because it can be interpreted many different ways depending on
the person perspective. He talks about dreams and he says “The dreamer is aware
that only everything else but this tiny dream exists and in this way the dream
itself is free to act without restraint.” To me this means that because we know
were dreaming, that consciousness allows are dreams to be very random. I think
dreams is a prime example of how important bewilderment is. Dreams are
confusing and in no way shape or form have to make sense or have valuable meaning
but still it is a part of humans sleep cycle. If there was no purpose of dreams
we wouldn't have them but we do showing that bewilderment is necessary. “He
says that the politics of bewilderment goes to those who have little or no
access to an audience or a government.” I thought this meant that people are
often confused by politics because there is no clear cut answer to many of the
thing that’s go on in our government. Everyone does not feel informed and that
where the confusion derives from. This is where bewilderment serves as a
negative because people would like solid answers solid and direct answers. This
shows the importance of certainty in the world. We need a balance of certainty and
bewilderment in the world to much of either is not ideal. My favorite part of
the reading is the last sentence where he says “After all the point of art-
like war- is show that life is worth living by showing that it isn't.” I
metaphor use in this sentence is what makes it so amazing, by art and war both
show how precious life is but the killing in war shows how valuable life is by
showing how invaluable it is.
I agree with Keenan's interpretations of the meanings of this reading in that when we dream if we know that we are indeed only dreaming the dreams are random and uncontrolled for the most part because if we did not know dream from reality we might not know when something could kill us. I agree that you are bewildered if you do not know what is going on in the government because it would come as a surprise to find something out that you had no clue about. All though it was a contradiction in his last sentence I believe it was intended to portray how valuable life is in contrast to the way people take their lives for granted.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with what you are saying, in Fanny Howes' article, "Bewilderment" is a mixture of what her knowledge of what bewilderment and certainty is and different stories that show this also. I think bewilderment is "being full of confusion and difficulty" and clearly I got this idea from what Fanny Howe said, "For me, bewilderment is like a dream: one continually returning pause on a gyre and in both my stories and poems it could be the shape of the spiral that imprints itself in my interior before anything emerges on paper." Dreams are random and uncontrolled, if dreams weren't like this we wouldn't be able to differentiate dreams from real life. Like Samuel said, a great interpretation by the way that is, "if we did not know dream from reality we might not know when something could kill you." People take there lives for granted at times, even though life is valuable.
ReplyDeleteI agree that this reading requires abstract thinking. I think we might have to be a little bewildered ourselves in order to fully understand it. I like your interpretation of the last sentence as well. I couldn’t quite understand it until I read your post. After reading this essay, I would say that bewilderment is the acceptance of life’s uncertainties. There isn’t one concrete answer for everything; everything can’t be determined. We are better off accepting this instead of struggling to find an answer for everything. I think bewilderment is necessary in our lives because it can give us a better understanding of life’s mysteries. Over-analyzing can cloud our vision. In this essay, Fanny Howe states, “If the dream’s curious activities are subjected to an excess of interpretation, they are better forgotten. The same demystification can happen with the close reading of a text; sometimes a surface reading seems to bring you closer to the intention of the poem.” Howe uses the interpretation of dreams and readings as an example of how over-analysis or trying too hard to determine an uncertainty can actually prevent us from finding the true meaning of that uncertainty. Certainty is also necessary in our lives because there are moments when we need simple, concrete answers. None of us want to go into a situation completely blind. We need certainty to make us feel confident, secure, and ready. I think your explanation of how bewilderment leads to confusion in politics is spot on. When it comes to politics, we need certainty in order for us to be well informed.
ReplyDeleteI as well believe that this reading requires a philosophical mindset because it deals with a lot of grey as opposed to seeing things in black and white or right and wrong. As you said in the last part of your blog entry, "... art and war both show how precious life is but the killing in war shows how valuable life is by showing how invaluable it is." What I got from this is that bewilderment is being certain about uncertainties. Certainty is necessary in our lives because we always want to be sure as to what is going on in our lives. It gives us a sense of accomplishment knowing that we reach a certain goal that we had set for ourselves. God is mentioned throughout this reading and it is an example of what we want to be certain of. To be certain that there is a Heaven that we can go to when we die instead of just dying and that being the end of our existence. Even something as simple as being certain that you are going to have food to eat when you wake up in the morning. Bewilderment is necessary in our lives because it forces us to think and interpret things to better understand them. Instead of life having no "flavor" it is full of wonders that we are intrigued by and want to discover. Fanny Howe interprets bewilderment to be like a dream because of how mysterious it they are to us.
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting how Howe doesn't choose certainty or bewilderment, a but combination of both. Here we can see the abstract element in her writings. I agree with your elaboration on the dreams, it is a positive example of bewilderment. But what if the dreamer was aware of his/her dreams? I have had instances when I knew I was dreaming but when I try to control my dream, I wake up, pretty bewildering but interesting! I don't think anything is 100% but we as humans like to believe that absolute certainty exist for our own comfort, because based on our past readings, we do not know what is determined or what is going to happen so how we can be certain? But then again that leads to the question "How do we know whats an actual situation of bewilderment and what is not?" This goes back to the point Howe makes in her writing, and you explain, of perspective. Like the government example you provided, the government like to make us think that certainty within their system exists but they are telling the public such things to gain their trust and to have them possess confidence in the government. Therefore, being that certainty and bewilderment are concepts that go hand in hand because there can not be a total presence of one, both co-exist and both are felt as well as seen in our world, so it think Howe makes a good point observing that necessity of both concepts.
ReplyDelete